Horse Inn

Horse Inn

Share

Come in and jump back in time. We are the oldest consecutively running restaurant in Lancaster city

Slightly off the beaten path, the Horse Inn restaurant has spent several generations striving to please its guests in Lancaster, PA. The main entrance was at one time on a narrow alleyway which, to this day, remains unnamed. In the early 1920s, the Shaub family renovated the second floor hayloft into a speakeasy. The original horse stalls were transported upstairs where wagon wheel chandeliers adorn the dining room.

The new owners of the Horse Inn, Matt and Starla Russell, have made several improvements to both the building and the menu. There are now two full bars and seating areas and a new, more accessible entrance on Fulton Street. Daily fresh ingredients and the use of local sources are crucial to Matt and Starla, who change the menu based on what is garden-fresh and in season. Don't worry; the infamous tenderloin tips on toast remain on the menu. The rich, brilliant dishes and one-of-a-kind cocktails will make you feel right at home.

11/03/2026

Cold Sesame Noodles

Wheat Noodles, Sesame & Peanut Sauce, Pickled Enoki Mushrooms, Pickled Red Onion, Fresh Cucumber, House-made Chili Crisp, Crispy Onions

A new savory bowl of goodness for y’all to kick off the week.
A rich peanut based sauce anchors this dish with the right amount of heat from the chili crisp, and a pop of freshness from pickled vegetables. Textures are spot on here.

Leave as is or add your favorite protein to it! Come try one!

Resy link in bio for reservations. Walk-ins encouraged!

See you soon.

10/30/2026

Happy Friday

The weekend is here. That calls for a plate of our tips n’ toast. A staple. Whether you just had it or it’s been a minute or two - we have plenty so come in tonight!

As we enter fall and our busiest time of year here we want to shout out to our staff and our guests. The latter make it worthwhile each week and the former keep the gears to this machine running day in and day out! Truly couldn’t ask for a better team or a better place to serve each night.

Resy link in bio for reservations. Walk-ins encouraged!

Bars are first come, first served.

We also recently added a lounge area so you can enjoy a drink while you wait.

See you soon.

10/24/2026

{ Through The Grapevine }

Old Overholt Rye Wh**ky, Concord Grape, Nux Alpina Nocino, Chai Tea, Lemon, Clarified w/ Whole Milk

A clarified milk punch feature for y’all. Limited batch. This one has been a hit. A perfect sipper for fall. Concord grape and rye wh**ky are best friends here.

Get one before it’s gone!

See you soon.

10/21/2026

Fresh Catch

Miso Compound Butter, Carrot Purée, Roasted Cauliflower, House-made Chili Crisp

A warm and comforting fish setup just hit our menu. A delicious balance of sweet & a touch of heat. Pairs perfectly with fresh pan seared cod from Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood

Come try it. See you soon.

Resy link in bio for reservations. Walk-ins encouraged!

10/16/2026

{ Jacob’s Tonic }

Luxardo Fernet, Spiced Mexican Coca-Cola, Old Bardstown Bourbon, Luxardo Maraschino, Lime

A fun one we bring back for y’all this time of year. A souped-up fernet & coke leaning into fall weather.

Come try one tonight! (And overtip)

See you soon!

10/13/2026

Old Fashioned Week 🥃

We have been participating in Old Fashioned Week with the folks over Elijah Craig who have also added us to their Tavern Trail featuring historic bars across the country. Also included is the lovely people Bulls Head Public House. Go see them too, they rock.

Come in and enjoy an Old Fashioned tonight. It’s pretty good. Don Draper would approve.

Easy link in bio for reservations. Bars first come first served.

See you soon.

10/08/2026

{ Slim Pickins }

Appleton Estate Signature Rum, Jerk Shrub, Allspice Dram, Lime, Tiki Bitters, Aqua Faba

A savory fall forward daiquiri for y’all! This one is just funky enough. Slightly spicy. We love a daiquiri around here and this one is a fun addition to that world.

We make a delicious shrub in house with local tomatoes, green onion, cilantro, habaneros, ginger, and lime. A touch of allspice dram sets off fall flavors and depth. Appleton Signature as always provides a warm run anchor.

Don’t miss it!
🍸: Cocktails&Concerts

10/07/2026

Beets & Arugula

Salt Roasted Beets, Lindendale Farms Goat Chèvre, Arugula, Pickled Onion, Radish, Toasted Pecans, Balsamic, Olive Oil

A new small plates dish landed on our menu last week and has been a hit. Come try one while these seasonal vegetables are peaking. Don’t miss out.

Resy link in bio for reservations. Walk-ins encouraged.

See you soon.

10/03/2026

Gemelli

Italian Sausage, Broccoli Rabe, Calabrian Chili, Parmesan Cream

A seasonal-transitional pasta dish just hit the menu. As the seasons change and jump back and forth between cooler and warmer days it creates an interesting challenge for restaurants to bridge that gap with dishes that feel warm and comforting but retain a bit of lightness. This dish does that perfectly.

Come try some!

Reservation link in bio. Walk-ins always welcome!

See you soon.

10/01/2026

PA Dutch Chicken & Waffles

A cozy comfort dish to ring in the cooler weather. Braised chicken. Waffles cooked to order. Savory gravy poured over top. The perfect balance for a fall dish.

Come try some tonight.

Want your business to be the top-listed Restaurant in Lancaster?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Telephone

Address


540 E Fulton Street
Lancaster, PA
17602

Opening Hours

Tuesday 5pm - 11pm
Wednesday 5pm - 11pm
Thursday 5pm - 11pm
Friday 5pm - 11pm
Saturday 5pm - 11pm

Other American restaurants in Lancaster

Show All
John J Jeffries John J Jeffries
300 Harrisburg Avenue
Lancaster, 17603

Sunday Dining: 5pm - 8pm Bar: 4pm - 10pm Mon. - Sat. Dining: 5pm - 9pm Bar: 4pm - 11pm

Heritage Hotel Lancaster and Loxley’s Restaurant Heritage Hotel Lancaster and Loxley’s Restaurant
500 Centerville Road
Lancaster, 17601

A dining experience central PA has never seen! Questions or comments? We would love to hear from you!

Conestoga Restaurant Conestoga Restaurant
1501 East King Street
Lancaster, 17602

Enjoy casual dining with a neighborhood feel at the Conestoga Restaurant; A remodeled historic landmark in Lancaster county right next to the Conestoga River. We offer American cu...

Mr. Pickle on Lemon Mr. Pickle on Lemon
323 W Lemon St
Lancaster, 17603

Breakfast, lunch and dinner daily. Open Friday and Saturday till 9. 323 W. Lemon St.

IHOP Lancaster PA - Lincoln Hwy E IHOP Lancaster PA - Lincoln Hwy E
2319 Lincoln Highway E
Lancaster, 17602

Any home can become a house of pancakes. Order on http://ihop.com for free delivery and 20% off your 1st order. See site for details. -- a Harvest Hospitalities franchise.

Neptune Diner Neptune Diner
924 N Prince Street
Lancaster, 17603

Step back into the '50s at the Neptune Diner and enjoy breakfast, lunch or dinner in a friendly atm.

Miller's Ale House Miller's Ale House
1000 Christopher Place
Lancaster, 17601

#1 Sports Bar in America. Where the Fans Go. Visit us at one of our locations in DE, FL, GA, IL, MD, NJ, NY, PA, TN & VA

Shake Shack Lancaster Shake Shack Lancaster
1100 Christopher Place Bldg. G
Lancaster, 17601

Shake Shack is serving up the best burgers, chicken, hot dogs, crinkle cut fries and milkshakes.

Cafe 24 Hundred Cafe 24 Hundred
Lancaster, 17602

Located at DoubleTree Resort by Hilton Lancaster, Cafe 24 Hundred is a great destination for contemporary casual dining, including patio seating and a full-service lounge.

Bridgeport Family Restaurant Bridgeport Family Restaurant
1655 Old Philadelphia Pike
Lancaster, 17602

Homestyle Cooking

TGI Fridays TGI Fridays
629 Park City Ctr
Lancaster, 17601

Ruby Tuesday of Lancaster Ruby Tuesday of Lancaster
2002 Fruitville Pike
Lancaster, 17601

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Horse Inn posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Subscribe

We will notify you when anything happens in Lancaster.